Great Karnataka Bicycle Taxi Turns

Karnataka’s electric bike taxi, scheduled to be released in 2021, has now been quietly dragged out of the road with a promise of clean, green, last-mile mobility. Originally to promote serious attempts to protect environmental transport, it was quickly lost in regulatory loopholes, law enforcement errors, and the kind of turf war that only Indian urban transport can actually deliver. By March 2024, the government pulled the spark plug on the grounds of a veritable buffet, from disguised whiteboard gasoline bikes disguised as electric taxis to safety issues, and selfless responses from ride-hailing aggregators. The electric hum that could have been gentle turned into a clumsy gasoline fuel mess, equipped with illegal rides, complaining unions and exciting regulators.

Instead of a whispering e-bike, Karnataka solves the ancient problem of how to get from the subway station to the front door (not stepping on the open manhole), but finds himself completely arguing with another beast. Private whiteboard bikes (usually gasoline-running, apparently violating the Automobile Act) were flooded on the streets, with many of them running under taxi umbrellas on bikes without chopping up legal cover. Confrontation between these riders and traditional automatic rickshaw drivers began to emerge, sometimes leading to street fighting on the territory. Women’s safety is considered a major issue, although one might say that claustrophobia is often less rare and safer on open two-wheelers, rather than inside a rattled, automatically rusty car, where grumpy drivers refuse to turn around.

Then there is the issue of aggregator’s interests, or the issue of lack of aggregator. Only one company even bothered to apply for a license, and they gave up halfway, just like a student giving up the paper midway through Chapter One. As a result, the government was besieged in the politically influential automatic rickshaw and cab unions to achieve its favorite tool: the blanket ban. That’s OK, this effectively flattened, not only for illegal petrol bike taxi, but for the policy to lure the future of the policy.

As of April 2025, Karnataka was trapped in a place that could only be described as a policy pothole – seemingly unable or unwilling to pave the way. On the one hand, there are clear demands for affordable, flexible last-mile mobility options. On the other hand, there is the traditional tape festival, regulatory chaos and the huge anger of automatic unions. For the average commuter, it is inconvenient to roll back suddenly by rolling back in a sudden on a bicycle taxi to work, subway, bus, college or home. You can’t ban the solution without an alternative, but this is never the operational logic of the government.

This is not to say that Karnataka cannot look around and borrow a page or two from other Indian states. Goa has had “pilots” for decades – bike taxis with yellow numbers, uniformed riders, locals and tourists amplify when they are in the narrow Bylanes and ferries. Cities in the Northeast (e.g. ramps and Ezar) are perfect for bike taxis, using them to browse hilly terrain and through tight urban clusters. However, in Bangalore, a city that often markets Indian technological capital, the entire plan is abandoned rather than fixed. Rather than putting safeguards (safety vest, GPS tracking or simple yellow wood boards) in place, the government chose to throw the baby, bath water and bathtub out of the window.

The reason for seeing a frequently repetitive whiteboard bike in the context is that car violations sound empty. In the Soviet era, Moscow was filled with pleasant Ladas chaos, doubling Ladas into an informal taxi, and no one seemed worse. In India, when low-income individuals find an honest way to make a living, especially in areas where the state fails to provide basic infrastructure, it is not only short-sighted but almost ridiculous to shut them down. Especially when these people clog the blanks in the last mile connection and create self-employed that does not exist.

Meanwhile, public transport in Bangalore continues to move forward. Now covering about 77 kilometers of subway throughout the city, the walking distance accounts for only 23% of the residents and 6% of the city’s total area. The extension plan looks good on paper and on a sleek manual, but commuters won’t travel on PowerPoint. They need the option that works today. BMTC is the city’s bus lifeline, which is actually lacking overstretching, underfunded, and has little to nowhere in many areas. Buses are either overcrowded or mysteriously missing, and in new layouts and external areas they are still as rare as punctual contractors.

In this chaos, bike taxis are good–Quick, cheap and agile, especially in Bangalore’s famous doomsday traffic. They can weave in potholes, sneak in and feel relieved for those who have to walk from subway stations, or negotiate with cars that would rather not be shorter. However, the government has not tightened the rules and improved enforcement, but has simply banned the whole thing.

To add to the ironic final notes, the state once promised its own ride-hailing app to offset senior committee fees charged by private platforms such as Ola and Uber. But, like most government technology projects, it has been “developed” for over a year, and they are all stuck between committee meetings and coding chaos. Meanwhile, aggregators like Rapido insist that they run in legal gray areas, the government insists that they are not, and users scratch their heads, unsure whether their next ride will appear, or be seized.

In March 2025, private transport unions once again entered the government’s doorstep, demanding a complete ban on bicycle taxis and reducing road taxes to prevent vehicles from registering in neighboring countries. So the game of push and pull continues, and the actual commuters are stuck in the middle.

But let’s be clear: while there is a fair case for bicycle taxi operators, they also have to be consistent with the conduct, at least the wise part of the law that everyone else follows. Playing according to the rules is not just legality, it is related to long-term credibility. If they really want to embed the urban transport matrix in India, they need to show that they are responsible stakeholders, not just rogue riders who rent wheels.

To be honest, Karnataka’s experiment with electric bike taxis was not a complete failure – it was a missed opportunity. It shows people’s desire for alternatives for cleaner, faster and more affordable options. But unless policies can keep up with innovation, the path to progress will remain full of speed bumps since the government learned to adjust with a scalpel instead of a sledgehammer. Dear readers, that’s a pity.

End of the article